|
All
scripture must be interpreted in its
context.
Context means we have to ask these
questions.
-
Who wrote this?
-
To
whom was it written?
-
Why was it written?
-
When was it written?
-
AUTHORSHIP
Is it important to know the
author?
When we ask who wrote the book, we
are actualy asking the question,
"What is the authority of book?"
Then the question will loom big. We
cannot term the book scripture
unless it has the authority. We
stake our life on the truthfulness
of the scripture.
What is the authority? Authority
cannot be based on subjective or
personal element. Holy Spirit
expresses itself through people and
therefore is liable to be mistaken
for other spirits. Hence the
statement, "The spirit told me"
cannot be basis of authority for the
church. Church itself cannot be an
authority over scriptures for the
same reason. The only objective
authority therefore is Jesus. Jesus
of Nazareth who incarnated and
revealed himself in human history.
Thus what we are looking for is what
is the authority of this book from
Jesus. Jesus could not have
corroborated the New Testament
books. Hence we rely on the next
line of authority - the authority of
the Apostles and those who were
close to them.

We
can know this in various ways.
-
-
Internal Evidence: The
author should tell us
directly or indirectly.
Directly by identifying
himself and indirectly by
circumstances style, diction
and references to persons
and events.
-
External Evidence: Others
should tell us. Historical
records, writings of early
fathers, cannons of the
church etc. form part of
these sources.
-
Internal Evidence:
Let
us apply this to the book of Hebrews
-
The book makes no direct
reference to the author: See the
beginning and conclusions of all
letter in the Bible.
-
Why did the writer omit the
identification?
It
is considered that Paul wrote it
to the Hebrews and he wanted
them to read it without the
baggage of his name. Jews would
have rejected the book coming
from Paul. So he deliberately
omitted it.
Alternately the Book of Hebrews
was not written as an epistle
but form part of some other
bigger epistle. At least one
manuscript makes this possible.
In an ancient manuscript of the
epistle of Paul to the Galatians
, soon after the grace the
entire book of Hebrews is added
with the subtitle: To the
Hebrews. Before closing the
Epistle to the Galatians, Paul
speaks about this epistle being
a large letter.
Gal 6: 10 Therefore, as we have
opportunity, let us do good to
all people, especially to those
who belong to the family of
believers. 11 See what large
letters I write to you with my
own hand!
Most interpreters assume that
Paul had some eye problem and
could not see small letters and
he wrote the book of Galatians
with his own hand in large
letter forms. However such an
interpretation is an imposed
interpretation since almost
always Apostles used traditional
scribes to transcribe the
epistles as they dictated them.
The scribe would then polish the
language and style according to
the need before sending it.
There is no reason to believe
that the Epistle to the
Galatians was any different. The
eye condition has nothing to be
concerned about. Even if it was
written by hand, all letters
written at the period were of
large sized, a minimum of one
inch size. This size would not
be any problem even with a weak
eye sight. It is therefore
reasonable to assume that Paul
is referring to the size of the
letter written which included a
letter to the Hebrews in
Galatia. This will explain why
the Salutations which are common
to all of Paul's letters are
missing in the Epistle to the
Hebrews.
The Salutation also indicates
that there were more than one
church in Galatia: "To the
churches in Galatia"
-
Let us analyse the Salutations
and final conclusions of the
Epistles found in the Bible:
|
Epistles |
Salutation |
Concludsion |
|
Romans |
Rom 1:1 Paul, a
servant of Christ Jesus,
called to be an
apostle..
7 To all in Rome |
Rom 15:33 The God of
peace be with you all.
Amen.16: 22 I, Tertius,
who wrote down this
letter, greet you in the
Lord….27 … to the only
wise God be glory
forever through Jesus
Christ! Amen. |
|
1 Corinthians |
1 Cor 1:1 Paul,
called to be an apostle
of Christ…..2 To the
church of God in
Corinth, |
1 cor. 16: 23 The
grace of the Lord
Jesus be with you.
24 My love to all of you
in Christ Jesus. Amen. |
|
2 Corinthians |
2 Cor 1:1 Paul,
an apostle of Christ..
To the church of God in
Corinth, |
2 cor. 13:14 May the
grace of the Lord
Jesus Christ, and the
love of God, and the
fellowship of the Holy
Spirit be with you all. |
|
Galatians |
Gal 1:1 Paul, an
apostle--To the churches
in Galatia: |
Gal 6: 18 The grace
of our Lord Jesus Christ
be with your spirit,
brothers. Amen. |
|
Ephesians |
Eph 1:1 Paul, an
apostle of Christ
Jesus…. To the saints in
Ephesus, |
Eph. 6: 24 Grace
to all who love our Lord
Jesus Christ with an
undying love. |
|
Philipians |
Phil 1:1 Paul and
Timothy, servants of
Christ Jesus,…. To all
the saints in Christ
Jesus at Philippi, |
23 The grace of the Lord
Jesus Christ be with
your spirit. Amen. |
|
Colosians |
Col 1:1 Paul, an
apostle of Christ… and
Timothy our brother,… 2
To the holy and faithful
brothers in Christ at
Colosse: |
Col 4: 18 I, Paul, write
this greeting in my own
hand. Remember my
chains. Grace be
with you. |
|
1 Thessolonians |
1 Th 1:1 Paul,
Silas and Timothy, To
the church of the
Thessalonians |
1 Th 5: 28 The grace
of our Lord Jesus Christ
be with you. |
|
2 Thessolonians |
2 Th 1:1 Paul,
Silas and Timothy, To
the church of the
Thessalonians |
2 Th. 3: 17 I, Paul,
write this greeting in
my own hand, which is
the distinguishing mark
in all my letters. This
is how I write. 18
The grace of our
Lord Jesus Christ be
with you all. |
|
1 Timothy |
1 Tim 1:1 Paul,
an apostle of Christ.. 2
To Timothy |
1 Tim 6:21…Grace
be with you. |
|
2 Timothy |
2 Tim 1:1 Paul,
an apostle of Christ… 2
To Timothy, |
2 Tim 4:22 The Lord be
with your spirit.
Grace be with you. |
|
Titus |
Titus 1:1 Paul, a
servant of God… 4 To
Titus, |
Tit. 3:15 Greet those
who love us in the
faith. Grace be
with you all. |
|
Hebrews |
|
Heb. 13:25 Grace
be with you all. |
|
Philemon |
Phile 1:1 Paul, a
prisoner of Christ
Jesus, and Timothy our
brother,. To Philemon |
25 The grace of
the Lord Jesus Christ be
with your spirit. |
|
James |
James 1:1 James,
a servant of God.. To
the twelve tribes
scattered among the
nations: Greetings. |
|
|
1 Peter |
1 Pet 1:1 Peter,
an apostle of Jesus
Christ, To God's elect,
strangers in the world,
scattered throughout
Pontus, Galatia,
Cappadocia, Asia and
Bithynia, |
1 Pe. 5: 13 She who is
in Babylon, chosen
together with you, sends
you her greetings, and
so does my son Mark.
14 Greet one another
with a kiss of love.
Peace to all of you who
are in Christ. |
|
2 Peter |
2 Pet 1:1 Simon
Peter, a servant and
apostle of Jesus Christ,
To those who through the
righteousness of our God
and Savior Jesus Christ
have received a faith |
2 Pe. 3:18 To him be
glory both now and
forever! Amen. |
|
1 John
|
|
|
|
2 John |
2 John 1:1 The elder,
To the chosen lady and
her children, |
13 The children of your
chosen sister send their
greetings. |
|
3 John |
3 John 1:1 The elder, To
my dear friend Gaius, |
The friends here send
their greetings. Greet
the friends there by
name. |
|
Jude |
Jude 1:1 Jude, a
servant of Jesus Christ
and a brother of James,
To those who have been
called, |
25 to the only God our
Savior be glory,
majesty, power and
authority, through Jesus
Christ our Lord, before
all ages, now and
forevermore! Amen. |
|
Authors of all
Epistles except
Hebrews and 1 John
identify themselves.
It was the practice
of Paul to conclude
every letter with
Grace with his own
hand. This was his
mark as he states in
2 The. 3:17.
Hebrews also ends
with Grace which is
the mark of Paul. |
|
3.
We can gather the following from the
Book.
-
-
The author was very familiar
with the Old Testament
Scriptures particularly with
the Septuagint version (LXX
a Greek translation of the
OT books by 70 authors
written 300 years before
Christ)
-
The author was a scholar of
the standing of a Rabi -
Professor. (Look at the
authoritative way of saying)
-
The author was familiar with
the practices of First
Century Jews (The
Kabbalistic slant of the
period)
-
The author may have been
familiar with the
hermeneutics of the first
century (midrash and
pesher): Refer to the temple
as shadow of things to come
and compare with Hagar
comparison and the rock that
followed Israel in Paul's
other letters. These are
typical Rabinic
hermeneutical methods.
-
External Evidence:
The
external evidence offers some
support for Pauline authorship, but
it is not unanimous nor definitive:
1.
Canons. Only the Athanasian
Cannon of the East has Hebrews in
it.
|
Marcion Canon (c. AD
140): It was
excluded from
Marcion's Canon, but
Marcion was a
Heretic by both the
East and the West.
Yet he was the first
historically to
enumerate the
cannon. He would not
have liked the
continuity between
the OT and the NT as
envisaged in the
book of Hebrews. His
theology was based
on two gods Yhvh the
demiurge of the OT
and Elohim the High
God of the NT.
Muratorian Canon (c.
170): was only a
fragment. It is
possible that the
area in question was
fallen off.
|
|
-
-
In The East: In the
East the epistle was
regarded as Pauline:
-
-
by Clement of Alexandria (c.
AD 150-215)
-
by Origen (c. AD 185-254)
-
Although Origen considered
the contents to be Pauline,
he was not actually certain
about who penned the book.
Most of Paul's letters were
penned by scribes or
disciples of his. He is
considered to have an eye
defect and could not see
properly. Even otherwise
most writings were penned by
special scribes or
secretaries. That does not
make the authorship to
change. Origen mentions that
some thought that Clement of
Rome, or Luke might have
been the author. Origen is
quoted by many reformers as
stating "But who wrote the
Epistle God only knows
certainly" (Guthrie, NTI, p.
686). However this was only
with regard to the style and
not with regard to the
authority.
-
By Athansian Cannon which
was of much later period
puts it as that of Paul's.
-
In Chester Beatty Papyrus (c
AD 200): The Chester Beatty
papyrus places the letter
among the Pauline
|
Epistles
after
Romans.
e. In one of
the ancient
manuscripts,
the book of
Hebrews
appears as
an appendix
to the Book
of Galatians
with the
title "To
the Hebrews"
|
|
|
-
-
In The West:
Initially it was not
considered Pauline
-
-
Tertullian: Tertullian (c.
AD 150-220) attributed it to
Barnabas
-
The Roman Church: The Roman
Church disputed Pauline
authorship, and this led
others to reject the Epistle
as canonical .
-
The Western Church: The
later Western Church was
influenced by the Eastern
Church in that although they
were not convinced of
Pauline authorship, they
compromised and proclaimed
Pauline authorship in a
unanimous way until the time
of the Reformation
-
Reformation: In the
Reformation Erasmus, Luther,
and Calvin all questioned
Pauline authorship of
Hebrews. Predestinarians
found this repungent and
Calvin relegated the book in
his bible as an appendix.
-
Bible Scholars such as
Mathew Henry, Scofield,
Dakes and Scot considered
Hebrews as Pauline.
|
Other Suggestions
Pauline authorship is denied
by many scholars because of
the following rasons: |
-
-
Anonymity: Nowhere in the
letter does the writer
identify himself as Paul;
this is very unlikely in
view of Paul's other
letters. Apostolic authority
is not mentioned either
-
Difference in Style: The
Greek style is not typical
of Pauline abruptness and
digressions; it is more
classical.
-
Absence of Pauline Spiritual
Experience: Paul always
introduced his own
experience with Christ and
his calling which is missing
in this epistle.
-
Theological Similarities and
Differences:
-
-
There are
theological
similarities
in this
letter with
Paul's other
writings:
1 . Faith is
an important
topic
2. The
majesty ,
radiance and
glory of the
Son is also
typical of
Paul.
3. Habakkuk
2:4 is
onlyquoted
by Paul
elsewhere in
the New
Testament
|
|
-
There are
theological
differences in
this letter with
Paul's other
writings:
-
The
exaltation
of Christ
rather than
resurrection
is
emphasized
-
The
redemptive
aspects of
Christ's
work rather
than the
sanctifying
aspects of
Christ's
work are
emphasized
-
The high
priesthood
of Christ is
nowhere else
emphasized
by Paul
|
|
-
-
Historical Difference:
Unlike Paul who emphasizes
that he did not receive the
gospel from men (Gal. 1--2),
this writer seems to have
received the gospel from
others13
-
Outside of Apostolic Circle:
The writer of Hebrews seems
to place himself outside of
the Apostolic circle
The
Western Churches considered Barnabas
as the author because of the
following reasons:
-
-
Early ecclesiastical Support
from the Western Churches
-
Barnabas was a Levite (Acts
4:36) and knew well the
temple rituals.
-
Barnabas was known as the
"Son of Consolation" (Acts
4:36) and Hebrews van be
interpreted as a letter of
encouragement (Heb. 13:22)
-
Hellenistic Characteristics.
Luther considered it as written by
Appolos.
-
-
Apollos'
close
acquaintance
with Paul
will explain
the Puline
concepts in
it .
-
His
connection
with
Alexandria,
which would
account for
the
Alexandrian
coloring
-
His
knowledge of
the
Scriptures,
which would
explain the
biblical
content of
the argument
and the use
of the LXX
version
-
His
eloquence,
which well
suits the
oratorical
form of the
Epistle.
-
He was close
to Timothy
|
|
|
However
there are no
traiditions
in this
support |
|
|
Harnack considers Priscilla as the
author and presents some interesting
reasons:
a)
Anonymity:
since a
woman would
not have
been
regarded
well as an
authority
source in
those time
she could
not have
mentioned
herself.
b) Her
association
with Paul
will explain
Pauline
concepts.
c) Her
instruction
of Apollos
shows her
scholarship
d) Hebrews
11 includes
several
women as
women of
faith. |
|
|
Other suggestions include Jude,
Luke, Clement, Silvanus, and Philip. |